So which drama wins?
*Please note this post is entirely based on my opinions
Storyline:
Tie
Even though I really like the storyline of SHR, it's a pretty common plot (girl travels through time and falls in love). The story would be a lot more unique and interesting if the drama focused more on the time travelling and differences between modern day Seoul and Goryeo.
MDBC is also a pretty common storyline where the female lead pretends to be a male. All in all both dramas have somewhat interesting storylines that aren't very original.
Camera Work:
Winner: Scarlet Heart Ryeo
Personally I preferred the camera work/angles for this drama over MDBC. The colours and lighting also made a big difference, where Scarlet Heart focused on more colourful clothes and imagery and MDBC focused more on the accuracy of historical facts.
Acting:
Winner: Moonlight Drawn By Clouds.
Even though I LOVED Lee Joon-Gi and IU's acting, overall MDBC had better actors that played their characters more convincingly. I was honestly concerned how innocent Park Bo Gum was going to play an arrogant crown prince, however he pulled off the role so well. Kim Yoo Jung's acting was also very realistic making me forget sometimes that her character is a female.
Probably the biggest reason why I chose MDBC over Scarlet Heart is because EXO's Baekhyun's acting in the first couple of episodes were not the greatest (he did improve later on however).
FINAL WINNER:
.
.
Scarlet Heart Ryeo
Even though I really enjoyed watching MDBC (especially Park Bo Gum <3), I was drawn more to Scarlet Heart's storyline. Scarlet Heart made we want to watch the drama EVERYDAY whereas MDBC I only felt like watching it once every two weeks. I actually kinda wished I held off watching the episodes of Scarlet Heart as they came out so I could marathon the series instead; I forgot how much torture it was to wait for new episodes.
Feel free to comment below on if you agree or disagree
Time for some Fan service ;)
Your welcome
*all gifs and images used were taken from Google Images